Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers should evaluate study design, statistical rigor, and clarity of conclusions. Feedback should be specific, respectful, and aimed at improving manuscript quality.
If ethical or integrity concerns are identified, reviewers should confidentially inform the editorial office.
Constructive reviews help authors improve clarity and strengthen the clinical value of their findings.
Comment on originality, methodological rigor, and whether conclusions are supported by the data. Prioritize major validity issues first, then note secondary improvements to guide efficient revisions.
Note whether the abstract and conclusions accurately reflect the results and suggest specific clarity improvements.
Declare conflicts early and decline quickly to avoid delays.
Conflict of Interest
Decline reviews when conflicts may affect objectivity.
Ethics
Flag concerns about consent, data integrity, or plagiarism.
